In a recent talk with Big Rigs, Greg Davies, a truck driver from Queensland, revealed that he received a hefty $580 fine for a minor logbook error while on a routine trip to Sydney.
Such an incident would highlight truck drivers’ stress levels and raise questions about whether these penalties have broad implications for the transport sector.
Truck Driver Greg Davies Fined $580 for a Simple Mistake
The Queensland truck driver, Greg Davies, was fined $580 at the Marulan weighbridge in NSW for forgetting to record a date in his logbook. Although his error was minor, officers issued the fine without allowing him to correct it.
Davies was in Sydney on a stressful trip, caring for his wife, who had recently suffered a heart attack. She accompanied him in the truck so he could keep an eye on her while continuing his work.
Just past midnight, after a hectic delivery at the Sydney markets, Davies drove towards Marulan, intending to let his wife rest and get breakfast.
In a rush, he forgot to record the date in his logbook—a minor oversight that led to a hefty fine and hostile treatment from compliance officers. This misadventure touched Davies, but more than that, it added needless pressure to his wife’s already-tense health status.
The Comparison: Truck Driver Greg Davies Fine vs Dangerous Driving Penalty
Aussie truck driver, Greg Davis also pointed out the television report that had focused on a case of a female driving with no registration and a suspended license while unbuckled with her two children in the car.
Law enforcement officers caught her speeding and probably found that she was not under the influence of meth, so they fined her just $300 for that.
“She went to court, got six months added to her suspension, and still paid less than me,” Davies said.
In such treatment disparities, glaring examples show the puzzle-like flaws regarding penalty enforcement.
For minor mistakes, a truck driver often has to pay a higher price than an ordinary person for even life-threatening, dangerous offences, which raises the question of how fair this system is.
Read More:
Truck Driver Greg Davies Incident at Marulan Weighbridge
Greg Davies described his encounter with compliance officers at the Marulan weighbridge as one of the most hostile experiences of his 27-year trucking career.
“The first fella came out and just yelled at me, ‘Logbook and licence!’” Davies said.
When Davies forgot to record the date in his logbook, officers refused to let him correct the oversight, instead issuing a $580 fine.
The tension heightened when a second police officer aggressively accused him of not attending to the issue of a broken headlight, although that was an entirely new issue.
“I told them that 99 per cent of officers would have just handed me back my logbook and let me scribble in the date,” Davis also said.
The officers were aggressive and unprofessional, leaving Davies feeling humiliated. He believes such treatment shows a lack of respect for drivers, especially those under personal stress.
Harsh Penalties Forcing Truck Drivers like Greg Davies Away from the Transport Industry
Greg Davies significantly reduces situations such as his, which drive many trucking practitioners away from the profession.
“Some of the fines handed to truck drivers are just ridiculous,” Davies said.
Regulations are necessary to guarantee safety, but unrealistic fines for minor infringements create undue stress for drivers under pressure. Education should replace punishment.
Otherwise, we are creating an industry that’s off-putting to newcomers and disrespectful towards veteran drivers. As if the industry is not already experiencing shortages of drivers, it keeps compounding the problem for the industry.
Appeals Process: Why the Fine Stuck for Australian Truck Driver Greg Davies
Greg Davies challenged the penalty, but he was not successful. The authorities relied upon his three petty offences in the past ten years as evidence of fatigue-related issues. His argument that the mistake was an honest-to-goodness confusion fell on deaf ears.
“I was stressed, but they didn’t care,” Greg Davies told Big Rigs.
The rigid appeals process left Davies feeling helpless. This situation has happened to many drivers without room for context or fairness. The consequent system focuses on penalties rather than fairness, making drivers feel targeted.
Davies’s case illustrates just how much these might be necessary: empathy in enforcing transport laws. The rules exist but must be enforceable through education rather than punishment.
A more empathetic approach could have prevented the unnecessary stress and humiliation Davies experienced and could have improved driver retention and support work in the industry.
That only puts extra pressure on the drivers by punishing them for a small mistake against all considerations. It is a hopeful system that will improve driver retention and support work.
This perception of truck drivers in Australia is fast changing because of awards like the Driver Salute Award program by the Victorian Transport Association, which recognizes individual drivers for their safe and disciplined driving habits.
